JournalWebsites

Redesign or Refresh? How to Decide What Your Website Needs

Jake Riff · · 5 min read

"Our website needs redoing" can mean anything from new photos to a new platform. Knowing which one you need saves money, because a refresh costs a fraction of a redesign, and saves time, because a redesign takes weeks a refresh doesn't.

The difference

A refresh keeps the site's structure and platform and improves what's on it: new photos, rewritten pages, clearer calls to action, fixes for speed and phones. A redesign rethinks the structure, look and often the platform, and rebuilds the site.

Neither is better. The right one depends on whether the foundations still fit your business.

Key takeawayRefresh when the foundations are sound and the content is tired. Redesign when the foundations no longer fit.

Signs a refresh is enough

  • The site works well on phones, it just looks a little dated.
  • You can update it yourself, and the platform does what you need.
  • The pages are right, but the words and photos are stale.
  • Inquiries come in, just fewer than you'd like.

Most of these are fixed with better content and a few focused changes. Start with the homepage headline, real photos and a contact page that works.

Signs it's time to redesign

  • It's hard to use on a phone, or slow no matter what you try.
  • You can't update it without calling someone, or you've lost access.
  • The business has changed: new services, a new audience, a store you can't add.
  • The platform can't do what you need, such as bookings, online sales or memberships.
  • You avoid sending people to it.

If several of these ring true, patching the old site usually costs more over time than starting fresh.

Key takeawayIf you're embarrassed to share the link, or can't change it yourself, it's probably time.

Take the quiz

QuizRedesign or refresh?
1How does the site work on a phone?
2Can you update it yourself?
3Has the business changed since the site was built?
4Does the platform do everything you need?
5How do you feel about sending people to it?
Answer all five to see the result.
ResultKeep it, and keep it current

Your foundations are fine. Regular upkeep is what matters; see the maintenance checklist.

ResultA refresh will likely do

Better words, photos and a few fixes, without rebuilding. Start with the pages people visit most.

ResultTime for a redesign

The foundations are holding you back. Start with a website brief and the prep list.

Either way, a free intro call is a good place to talk it through: scope your project and you'll see a typical price range for a refresh or a full redesign as you go.

How Riff Web Design can helpWebsite redesignA new look is the easy part.See redesigns Written byJake RiffDesigns and builds websites for small businesses at Riff Web Design.About Jake

Keep reading

Want help putting this into practice?