JournalE-commerce

What Is a Good Conversion Rate? A Calculator for Small Stores

Jake Riff · · 6 min read

Most store owners watch traffic. The number that usually matters more is conversion rate: how many of those visitors actually buy. A small lift there is often worth more than a big jump in visitors, and it costs less to get.

What conversion rate means

Conversion rate is the share of visits that end in an order. If 2,000 people visit your store in a month and 40 of them buy, your conversion rate is 2%.

Shopify shows it on the main analytics dashboard. Squarespace shows it under Analytics, in Sales. In Google Analytics 4 you'll find it once purchases are tracked as key events. Whichever you use, compare it month to month on the same tool, since each one counts visits a little differently.

Run your numbers

Move the sliders to match your store. The bottom figure shows what half a percentage point more in conversion would be worth, with the same traffic you have today.

CalculatorWhat is a better conversion rate worth?
Orders a month
30
Sales a month
$1,800
Extra sales a month at +0.5%
$600
Over a year
$7,200

Sales figures, before costs. Your numbers stay in your browser.

Try it with your own figures. For most small stores, the jump from a better product page or a smoother checkout is worth more than the same effort spent on getting more traffic, because you're making better use of visitors you already pay to attract.

What counts as good

You'll find plenty of published "average conversion rates", and they vary a lot by source, industry, price point and how visits are counted. A store selling $20 candles and a store selling $900 furniture shouldn't expect the same number.

The benchmark that matters most is your own. Note your rate for the last three months, make one change, and see whether it moves. A store going from 1.2% to 1.6% has improved by a third, whatever any industry chart says.

Key takeawayCompare yourself with yourself. The trend in your own rate tells you more than any industry average.

Where shoppers drop off

Every store loses people at each step on the way to an order. The shape below is an illustration, not real data, but it's the pattern you'll see in your own reports: big drops early, and a painful one at checkout.

The path to an orderIllustration: out of every 100 visits
  1. Visit the store100
  2. View a product55
  3. Add to cart12
  4. Start checkout6
  5. Place the order2

Shopify's analytics include a conversion funnel report with these steps for your store. Look for the biggest drop. That's where your first fix goes.

Fixes that move it

1Few visitors view a product

The homepage or collection pages aren't leading anywhere. Make the main products visible straight away, with clear photos and prices, and make sure the menu uses words customers use.

2Views but few add to cart

The product page isn't answering questions. Add better photos, sizing or dimensions, delivery times, the returns policy and real reviews close to the button.

3Carts but few checkouts

Surprises cost sales. Show shipping costs early, offer the payment methods people expect, such as Shop Pay, Apple Pay and PayPal, and don't force account creation.

4Checkouts but few orders

Test the checkout yourself on a phone. Slow pages, discount code boxes that send people off hunting for codes, and broken shipping rules are all common. A cart recovery email will win some of these back.

Measure before you change

Write down your current rate before you change anything, then change one thing at a time and give it a few weeks. Seasonal swings, sales and ad campaigns all move the number, so compare like with like.

If the numbers look wrong, they may be. Duplicate tracking, missing purchase events and bot traffic all distort conversion rates. The post on setting up GA4 covers how to check.

Key takeawayFind the biggest drop in your funnel, fix that one step, and measure. Repeat.
How Riff Web Design can helpE-commerce strategyWhat to sell where, how to price and present it, and which apps and systems the store actually needs.See e-commerce strategy Written byJake RiffDesigns and builds websites for small businesses at Riff Web Design.About Jake

Keep reading

Want help putting this into practice?