JournalE-commerce

Shopify vs WooCommerce: Which Is Right for a Small Store?

Jake Riff · · 7 min read

Both platforms run successful stores of every size. The right choice depends less on features and more on how you want to spend your time: running the store, or running the website the store sits on.

The short answer

Shopify is a hosted service. You pay monthly and Shopify handles hosting, security, updates and checkout. You give up some control in exchange for very little upkeep.

WooCommerce is a free plugin that turns a WordPress site into a store. You choose your own hosting, and you can change almost anything, but keeping it updated, secure and fast is your job, or your developer's.

Key takeawayShopify trades control for convenience. WooCommerce trades convenience for control.

Side by side

CompareHighlight where each one is stronger
ShopifyWooCommerce
SetupSign up and start; hosting is includedNeeds WordPress, hosting and setup first
Monthly costPlan fee, plus apps and payment feesPlugin is free; you pay for hosting, extensions and payment fees
UpkeepShopify handles updates and securityYou update WordPress, the theme and plugins
CheckoutFast, familiar, with Shop Pay built inGood, but depends on setup and hosting
FlexibilityWide, within Shopify's rulesAlmost anything, with code
Content and bloggingBasic blog and pagesAll of WordPress
Owning your dataExportable, but hosted by ShopifyOn your own hosting

Where Shopify wins

Shopify is the safer bet for most small stores whose owners want to spend their time on products and customers. Checkout is fast and trusted, there's no server to look after, and the app store covers most needs: reviews, subscriptions, wholesale, marketplaces. It also connects cleanly to marketplaces like Amazon, Google and social shops.

The trade-off is cost creep. Apps add monthly fees, and some things that are simple in WordPress, like unusual product options or custom checkout steps, need apps or workarounds in Shopify. The post on Shopify's monthly costs has a calculator for the full bill.

Where WooCommerce wins

WooCommerce suits stores where content matters as much as the catalog, such as a business with a large blog, courses, or a membership area, and stores that need something truly custom. It's also a natural fit if you already run a well-kept WordPress site.

The trade-off is upkeep. Updates, backups, security and speed are all on you. A WooCommerce store on cheap hosting with twenty plugins will be slow and fragile. Set up well and maintained, it's excellent.

Take the quiz

Five quick questions. Pick the answer closest to your situation.

QuizWhich platform fits your store?
1Who will keep the site updated?
2How important is blog and page content?
3Do you already have a WordPress site?
4How unusual are your products or checkout?
5Which matters more?
Answer all five to see your result.
Your resultShopify is likely the better fit

You want a store that runs itself while you focus on selling. See Shopify design.

Your resultIt's close: look at the detail

Either could work. The deciding factor is usually who maintains it. A strategy session can settle it.

Your resultWooCommerce is likely the better fit

You need control and content more than convenience. See WordPress and custom sites.

Switching later

You're not locked in forever. Stores move between the two regularly. Products, customers and order history can all be migrated, and with redirects in place you keep your search rankings. It's a project, not a weekend task, so it's worth choosing carefully now. The migration checklist covers what's involved.

Key takeawayPick the platform that matches who will run it. That matters more than any feature list.
How Riff Web Design can helpShopify web designA Shopify store that looks like your brand, loads fast on a phone and is set up to sell: products, collections, checkout, shipping, apps and tracking.See shopify stores Written byJake RiffDesigns and builds websites for small businesses at Riff Web Design.About Jake

Keep reading

Want help putting this into practice?