JournalE-commerce

Should Your Brand Sell on Amazon? A Plain Look at the Trade-offs

Jake Riff · · 3 min read

Amazon has an enormous audience of shoppers ready to buy, and for many products it is where people search first. That makes it tempting for every brand with its own store. Whether it is worth it comes down to margin, product and how much control you are willing to give up.

What a marketplace gives you

The main benefit is reach. Shoppers who would never find your website search Amazon for the type of product you make. A marketplace also brings trust, because people already know how to buy and return there, and with Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA), fast delivery that would be hard to match on your own.

Walmart Marketplace works in a similar way with a different, often smaller, set of shoppers and sellers. For some categories that means less competition.

What it costs

Marketplace fees add up quickly, and they come out of the same margin that pays for everything else. Before listing, work out the real profit per sale after all of them.

  • Referral fees: a percentage of each sale, varying by category
  • Fulfillment and storage fees, if you use FBA
  • Advertising: on Amazon, sponsored ads are often needed to be seen
  • Returns, and the products that come back unsellable
  • Your time, or someone's, to manage listings and the account

Fee schedules change and differ by category, so use the marketplaces' own current fee calculators rather than an estimate from an article.

Key takeawayIf a product only makes money on your own store, it probably won't make money on Amazon.

FBA or ship it yourself

With FBA, you send inventory to Amazon's warehouses and they handle storage, shipping, returns and customer service for those orders. It can help with Prime eligibility, which matters to many shoppers. In return you pay fulfillment and storage fees, and slow-moving stock gets expensive to store.

Shipping orders yourself keeps more control and avoids storage fees, but you need to meet the marketplace's shipping standards. Many sellers use FBA for fast movers and ship slower or oversized items themselves. Run the numbers product by product.

Protect your own store

Selling on a marketplace shouldn't mean undercutting yourself. If the same product is cheaper on Amazon, many of your own customers will buy it there, and you'll pay a fee on a sale you would have made anyway.

Plan pricing across channels together. Some brands keep prices the same everywhere; others sell bundles, sizes or product lines on marketplaces that aren't on their own site, or the other way round. And remember that marketplace customers belong to the marketplace. Your own store is where you build an email list and repeat customers.

Listings that sell

A marketplace listing has to work harder than a product page on your own site, because it sits next to competitors. The basics matter most.

  • A clear title with the words shoppers actually search
  • A clean main image that meets the marketplace's rules, plus lifestyle and detail shots
  • Bullets that answer the questions in your reviews and returns
  • A+ content, if your brand is registered, to tell the brand story
  • A steady stream of honest reviews

Start small

You don't have to list your whole catalog. Start with a few products that have good margins, steady demand and few returns. Watch the real profit for a couple of months, including ad spend, then expand what works and pull what doesn't.

A marketplace should add profit, not just revenue.

If you're weighing up Amazon or Walmart, or already selling and unsure it's paying off, see Amazon and marketplaces. Running Amazon and Walmart.com channels in-house is where much of this advice comes from.

How Riff Web Design can helpAmazon & marketplacesSeller Central, Amazon ads and Walmart listings, set up so marketplaces add sales instead of undercutting your own store.See amazon & marketplaces Written byJake RiffDesigns and builds websites for small businesses at Riff Web Design.About Jake

Keep reading

Want help putting this into practice?